A Memoir from the Wetlands/Stuck in the Middle/The Other Side of The Coin


For over a decade, I've listened to the stories of people displaced by climate disasters. I've seen how easily one’s identity can be swept away by the rain or crushed as their house is demolished.


In 2008, after a much-contested presidential election in Zimbabwe, settlers began to build housing structures along the Monavale Vleis. ‘Stuck in the Middle’ is a visual story about people living on borrowed time. These communities are vulnerable to health hazards not only to man- made (technological) hazards, but also natural hazards, including health hazards, as the area is prone to flooding. Human settlements on the Monavale vleis, and other wetlands, are a constant threat to the conservation of wetlands and their biodiversity.


In May 2013, Zimbabwe became a contracting party to the Convention on Wetlands with a total of five wetland sites labelled ‘of international importance’. Established in 1971 in Ramsar, Iran, the Convention advocates for the wise use of wetlands and the ecosystem supporting it. Today, Zimbabwe has a total of seven wetlands designated as ‘Ramsar Sites’ and these are: Chinhoyi Caves Recreational Park, Cleveland Dam, Driefontein Grasslands, Lake Chivero and Manyame, Mana Pools National Park, Monavale Wetland (vleis) and Victoria Falls National Park.


Human settlements on the Monavale vleis, and other wetlands, are contributing to the pollution of the wetland as refuse collection services are unavailable to the area – deemed to be unauthorized structures. Unfortunately, a flow of sludge, heaps of plastic, paper, diapers and ‘houses’ are slowly obstructing and replacing the wetland. Because of this clash between nature and the need for housing, the communities are stuck between the threat of a natural disaster and the doom of demolition courtesy of the local council.


This story will engage communities living along the Monavale Wetland which was normally characterised by Miombo woodland, a vleis and open grassland prior to occupation. The vleis just under 600ha in size and only 34ha is under full protection. There is a strong legal framework in place to enforce the protection of the wetland however, due to insufficient political will, inefficiencies or a lack of resources, the level of implementation and enforcements has been lacklustre.


As the rainfall season approaches, the houses in these suburbs are at risk of flooding, as most are built either too close or on the wetlands. With each flooding season, residents watch as their furniture and home devices are swallowed by the water and, at worst, some lose their lives in the flooding. Independent collectives such as residents’ associations and conservationists, have been lobbying for the reduction of borehole drilling and construction on wetlands.


This story will showcase the perspectives of the communities living on the wetland as their stories are rarely told outside of a crisis. It will delve into the impact of human settlements on the Monavale Vleis – the ecology and quality of life there. It will feature visuals of the water damage to housing infrastructure and share the advocacy efforts on conserving the wetlands. The project is meant to encourage readers and viewers to understand and champion the conservation of wetlands.


Striking a balance between urbanisation and conservation in Zimbabwe will require a collaborative and integrated approach. For this and future generations, we need to address the impact climate change, the loss of biodiversity and pollution have on our wetlands and communities as well.

info
In Budiriro 4, a high density suburb in the capital city, a string of houses have been built across the expanse of the Monavale Wetland in Harare, Zimbabwe, November 15, 2024.
The area is demarcated by the city's old sewer pipes, and the land is soggy and prone to flooding during the rainy season.
Photo by Charmaine Chitate for The VII Foundation
×
In Budiriro 4, a high density suburb in the capital city, a string of houses have been built across the expanse of the Monavale Wetland in Harare, Zimbabwe, November 15, 2024.
The area is demarcated by the city's old sewer pipes, and the land is soggy and prone to flooding during the rainy season.
Photo by Charmaine Chitate for The VII Foundation
×
info
It takes Shillah Zvomoyo, and her colleague, two days to complete constructing a Blair toilet in Harare, Zimbabwe, November 08, 2024.
The increasing construction activities on the wetland have led to poor urban planning as the buildings are neither sited nor supervised by the local authority.
Photo by Charmaine Chitate for The VII Foundation
×
It takes Shillah Zvomoyo, and her colleague, two days to complete constructing a Blair toilet in Harare, Zimbabwe, November 08, 2024.
The increasing construction activities on the wetland have led to poor urban planning as the buildings are neither sited nor supervised by the local authority.
Photo by Charmaine Chitate for The VII Foundation
×
Two school boys making their way home through one of many dump sites filled with plastics, diapers, paper, tin cans and clothing materials are strewn randomly across the wetland, providing a breeding ground for pests in Harare, Zimbabwe, November 08, 2024
info

Two school boys making their way home through one of many dump sites filled with plastics, diapers, paper, tin cans, and clothing materials are strewn randomly across the wetland, providing a breeding ground for pests in Harare, Zimbabwe, November 08, 2024. Due to their status as 'unauthorised structures' the community does not have access to refuse collection services allowing the wind to blow the rubbish into the wetland's main water stream, contaminating it. Photo by Charmaine Chitate for The VII Foundation

×

Two school boys making their way home through one of many dump sites filled with plastics, diapers, paper, tin cans, and clothing materials are strewn randomly across the wetland, providing a breeding ground for pests in Harare, Zimbabwe, November 08, 2024. Due to their status as 'unauthorised structures' the community does not have access to refuse collection services allowing the wind to blow the rubbish into the wetland's main water stream, contaminating it. Photo by Charmaine Chitate for The VII Foundation

×
Chantelle Jonhera (22) hand washes her family's laundry at least once a week and there are at least 20 households on her street doing the same in Harare, Zimbabwe, November 15, 2024.

The grey water, filled with detergents, flows into the wetland, degradi
info

Chantelle Jonhera (22) hand washes her family's laundry at least once a week and there are at least 20 households on her street doing the same in Harare, Zimbabwe, November 15, 2024. The grey water, filled with detergents, flows into the wetland, degrading it over time. As the wetland's vegetation is cut off to make way for more construction activities, it is losing its ability to purify water and make it safe for other species. Photo by Charmaine Chitate for The VII Foundation

×

Chantelle Jonhera (22) hand washes her family's laundry at least once a week and there are at least 20 households on her street doing the same in Harare, Zimbabwe, November 15, 2024. The grey water, filled with detergents, flows into the wetland, degrading it over time. As the wetland's vegetation is cut off to make way for more construction activities, it is losing its ability to purify water and make it safe for other species. Photo by Charmaine Chitate for The VII Foundation

×
Chantelle Jonhera (22) sells hair combs, lip glos and body oils to raise money to buy items on her baby preparation list in Harare, Zimbabwe, November 15, 2024.

The rising unemployment rate in Zimbabwe has created opportunities on the informal market how
info

Chantelle Jonhera (22) sells hair combs, lip gloss, and body oils to raise money to buy items on her baby preparation list in Harare, Zimbabwe, on November 15, 2024. The rising unemployment rate in Zimbabwe has created opportunities in the informal market however, these are easily disrupted in the face of a disaster, crippling a much-needed source of income for the household.   Photo by Charmaine Chitate for The VII Foundation

×

Chantelle Jonhera (22) sells hair combs, lip gloss, and body oils to raise money to buy items on her baby preparation list in Harare, Zimbabwe, on November 15, 2024. The rising unemployment rate in Zimbabwe has created opportunities in the informal market however, these are easily disrupted in the face of a disaster, crippling a much-needed source of income for the household.   Photo by Charmaine Chitate for The VII Foundation

×
Six months pregnant, with a toddler in tow, Chantelle feels overwhelmed by her household chores in Harare, Zimbabwe, November 23, 2024.

Her sister, Glavender Jonhera (28), used to walk five kilometres to visit her. Now she has moved in to help ease the w
info

Six months pregnant, with a toddler in tow, Chantelle feels overwhelmed by her household chores in Harare, Zimbabwe, on November 23, 2024. Her sister, Glavender Jonhera (28), used to walk five kilometres to visit her. Now she has moved in to help ease the workload, help her sister stay healthy, and deliver a healthy baby.   Photo by Charmaine Chitate for The VII Foundation

×

Six months pregnant, with a toddler in tow, Chantelle feels overwhelmed by her household chores in Harare, Zimbabwe, on November 23, 2024. Her sister, Glavender Jonhera (28), used to walk five kilometres to visit her. Now she has moved in to help ease the workload, help her sister stay healthy, and deliver a healthy baby.   Photo by Charmaine Chitate for The VII Foundation

×
The shallow well makes it easy for,Chantelle Jonhera (22), to drawing water for her household chores in Harare, Zimbabwe, November 23, 2024.

During the rainy season the septic tank at her household floods and overflows into the shallow well, as with many
info

The shallow well makes it easy for, Chantelle Jonhera (22), to draw water for her household chores in Harare, Zimbabwe, November 23, 2024. During the rainy season the septic tank at her household floods and overflows into the shallow well, as with many other houses in the area. Photo by Charmaine Chitate for The VII Foundation

×

The shallow well makes it easy for, Chantelle Jonhera (22), to draw water for her household chores in Harare, Zimbabwe, November 23, 2024. During the rainy season the septic tank at her household floods and overflows into the shallow well, as with many other houses in the area. Photo by Charmaine Chitate for The VII Foundation

×
Chantelle Jonhera (22) helps her daughter, Dilara Chinyanga (32 mo) wear shoes outside their home in Harare, Zimbabwe, November 23, 2024. 

Chantelle hopes to live in a safe space where she can raise Dilara and her unborn child without fear - a constituti
info

Chantelle Jonhera (22) helps her daughter, Dilara Chinyanga (32 mo) wear shoes outside their home in Harare, Zimbabwe, November 23, 2024. Chantelle hopes to live in a safe space to raise Dilara and her unborn child without fear - a constitutional right in Zimbabwe (Section 73). Photo by Charmaine Chitate for The VII Foundation

×

Chantelle Jonhera (22) helps her daughter, Dilara Chinyanga (32 mo) wear shoes outside their home in Harare, Zimbabwe, November 23, 2024. Chantelle hopes to live in a safe space to raise Dilara and her unborn child without fear - a constitutional right in Zimbabwe (Section 73). Photo by Charmaine Chitate for The VII Foundation

×
Left, Glavender Jonhera (28) and Chantelle Jonhera (22) posing for a picture at the latter'shomestead in Harare, Zimbabwe, November 23, 2024.
 
The conservation of the wetland is highly dependent on a collaborative effort between urban developers and cons
info

Left, Glavender Jonhera (28) and Chantelle Jonhera (22) posing for a picture at the latter's homestead in Harare, Zimbabwe, November 23, 2024.   Wetland conservation is highly dependent on a collaborative effort between urban developers and conservationists to ensure the addressing of housing needs and the preservation of the environment.   Photo by Charmaine Chitate for The VII Foundation

×

Left, Glavender Jonhera (28) and Chantelle Jonhera (22) posing for a picture at the latter's homestead in Harare, Zimbabwe, November 23, 2024.   Wetland conservation is highly dependent on a collaborative effort between urban developers and conservationists to ensure the addressing of housing needs and the preservation of the environment.   Photo by Charmaine Chitate for The VII Foundation

×
Chantelle Jonhera (R) 'feeding' braids to her mother-in-law Pauline Machona as she plaits her sister Blessing Machona. in Harare, Zimbabwe, November 15, 2024.

In the meantime, life continues. The community is growing and generating income streams in the
info

Chantelle Jonhera (R) 'feeding' braids to her mother-in-law Pauline Machona as she plaits her sister Blessing Machona. in Harare, Zimbabwe, November 15, 2024. In the meantime, life continues. The community is growing and generating income streams in the informal sector. As they smile and brave living on the wetland, thoughts of a flood and a possible demolishing of what they built and bought with their hard-earned money loom. Photo by Charmaine Chitate for The VII Foundation

×

Chantelle Jonhera (R) 'feeding' braids to her mother-in-law Pauline Machona as she plaits her sister Blessing Machona. in Harare, Zimbabwe, November 15, 2024. In the meantime, life continues. The community is growing and generating income streams in the informal sector. As they smile and brave living on the wetland, thoughts of a flood and a possible demolishing of what they built and bought with their hard-earned money loom. Photo by Charmaine Chitate for The VII Foundation

×